Dell Dominate Printers and PDAs? Puhlease!?

Dell’s generating lots of noise about its planned foray into the branded printer and PDA business, but they’re clearly drinking their own Kool-Aid if they think they’re going to turn the markets around overnight.

In the case of printers, where Dell already resells about 2 million units per year, the company faces huge stumbling blocks in gaining market share from market leader HP, which has 47% of the standard printer market according to IDC. That’s more than twice the market share of Dell’s new buddy, Lexmark, which found itself forced to seek other prospects after the HP/Compaq merger last spring. While Dell’s cozying up gave Lexmark’s stock a short-term burst, many industry watchers believe that the company will ultimately discover that its agreement with Dell is a Faustian bargain, and that over time its financials will be bled white by the deal.

On the PDA front, Dell is even further in the hole, having to start from scratch with zero base of sales and a reliance on low-ball, margin-squeezed overseas contract OEMs for product. As Dell tries to focus on capturing enterprise sales for its new PDA, they face serious obstacles and backlash from the long-scorned sales channel. As Frank Gillette, an analyst at Forrester Research, explained, "Dell is an arms merchant. They don’t have allegiances."

Despite all the hype over Dell’s dive into the pool of printers and PDAs, Round Rock won’t see serious bottom line benefits for some time. "Dell is not going to suddenly have 10% to 15% of its revenue come from printers," said Brent Bracelin of Pacific Crest Securities. Andy Neff at Bear Stearns estimates that the Lexmark agreement won’t mean much to Dell’s financials until late 2004 or even 2005. Michael Dell himself admits that printer sales for Dell in the first full year might total only $150-300 million, or about .5 – 1% of total revenues.

©2002 Technology Intelligence Pulse